Tailoring Engagement: Building Connections that Last

[Sign up to the Downtown Newsletter]

Last month, we looked deeper into the fans behind the streams, moving beyond spending metrics to understand the emotional and cultural drivers of fandom. This month, we turn to what it takes to build meaningful, lasting fan connections — and why those connections matter.

Larger companies may have access to entire teams dedicated to analysing audiences and what drives them. Smaller labels often have fewer resources, and may not be able to follow suit in the same way. Instead, they tend to rely more on direct, anecdotal experience, which is incredibly valuable and often rooted in a deep connection to their communities. But that same closeness can also come with blind spots.

Regardless of resources or approach, developing a meaningful understanding of what drives fans is what ultimately allows for engagement that goes beyond transactions. At its core, fans need to feel that they’re getting out as much as they’re putting in — whether that’s their time, money, advocacy, or passion. In other words: why should they care about you, if they don’t believe you care about them?

This doesn’t have to require large-scale data analysis, or even complex research. Most labels innately understand their audience because they’re active members of the community themselves. What it does require is an active thought process considering what the audience needs and deserves, what they’ve come to expect from their community, and how the artist in question fits into—and stands out against—that context.

Below is a condensed example of a ‘core values’ analysis, showing three segments within an artist’s fan base. Understanding identity markers in this way can help guide decision making, across multiple audiences within a fandom, and ensure you’re providing the right value for each.

For example, some electronic music subgenres have built tight-knit communities where engagement is driven by shared experiences rather than exclusive merchandise. Modern Trance fans are some of the most dedicated and loyal in the world of Dance & Electronic, thanks to the culture of reciprocity artists maintain with the community. Many of the top artists routinely uplift lesser-known producers through remix contests and shared platforms, and take the time to acknowledge each other and their community. Artists like Armin van Buuren host fans from around the globe on their radio shows, offering space for them to share memories, articulate their fandom, and connect with one another – ultimately participating in their own community rather than simply profiting from it.  Messaging around love, unity, and euphoria is consistent across lyrics, visuals, events, and social channels, reaffirming the audience’s reason for participating, and reinforcing the emotional connection of the music and community.

Monstercat, on the other hand, has carved out a thriving ecosystem by understanding the intersection of its audience’s interests, particularly the overlap of electronic music and gaming culture. With a focus on energetic subgenres like Dubstep, Drum & Bass, Electro, and Future Bass, the label appeals to production-savvy fans and gamers alike. Since 2017, Monstercat has partnered with Rocket League, and has produced soundtrack albums for games like Fortnite and Beat Saber. Their 2022 event included a dedicated Gaming Zone, and they maintain high-performing gaming playlists across platforms like Spotify and YouTube. The label’s visual identity is marked by fantasy, cartoon, and gaming-inspired artwork, further consolidating its identity and giving fans more of what they originally came for.

This kind of connected ecosystem is about more than just engagement. Engaged audiences provide a kind of fandom capital that transcends any single platform. It means an artist’s engagement isn’t tied to a specific social network, marketing channel, or release strategy. Instead, it can transfer across platforms, formats, and opportunities, because the fan is connected to the artist, not just the content. A rough analogy might be one’s financial credit score: a value that influences individual interactions, and is in turn influenced by them, regardless of the specific bank or financial instrument. Unlike a credit score, however, this kind of fan value is essentially impossible to reduce to a single number, and therefore requires trust that the work to maintain it is key to long term career success. Investing in a more nuanced understanding of fandom that is rooted in real audience insights rather than just spending metrics, artists can cultivate more meaningful relationships with their listeners, which go beyond specific platforms. This kind of connection is what turns listeners into lifelong supporters,  and it’s what helps artists build audiences, not just attention.

In our next instalment, we’ll look at some of these ideas in practice, and how they can share campaigns and careers.